We deliver to within 15 miles of our store! Click here for details.

Upcoming Events/Deadlines:

6th Annual Berks County: Hometown Thanksgiving Cheesecake Parking Lot Sale- Sat., November 22, 2025, 10 am-2 pm

Location: Rita’s Italian Ice Parking Lot, 101 East Main St., Birdsboro, PA.

For pre-order instructions, CLICK HERE.

Pittsburgh Thanksgiving Holiday Order Deadline:

Friday, November 21, 2025 at 5 pm.

There are two options for ordering your Thanksgiving cheesecakes in Pittsburgh. Pickup or Delivery. CLICK HERE FOR DETAILS!


See our Events Calendar page for our scheduled events and Farmers markets!

Our Seasonal Favorites!

Caramel Apple Cheesecake slice

Caramel Apple Cheesecake

Cinnamon apples are layered into this cheesecake and baked on top of a buttery, cinnamon graham cracker crust. Our signature sour cream layer tops this cheesecake along with our scratch-made salted caramel. Available in a 9-inch cheesecake or a three pack of mini 4-inch cheesecakes.

Order Now!

Classic Pumpkin Cheesecake

Ya know what’s better than pumpkin pie at Thanksgiving? Pumpkin cheesecake. But don’t wait for the holidays! Our creamy pumpkin cheesecake has just the right touch of cinnamon and nutmeg. Our signature sour cream layer, with a hint of cinnamon, tops this creamy cheesecake.

ORDER NOW!
Peanut Butter Buckeye Cheesecake

Peanut Butter Buckeye Cheesecake

This rich, creamy Peanut Butter Cheesecake is baked on top of a chocolate cookie crust. Our signature sour cream layer with a hint of added peanut butter tops this delicious cheesecake along with our scratch-made chocolate ganache. Available in a 9-inch cheesecake or a three pack of mini 4-inch cheesecakes.

Order Now!

Last night in Greensburg's Night market, we picked up a Key Lime cheesecake. Oh my goodness, without giving our exact retired ages, it was the very best cheesecake we both ever experienced. It was so light and fluffy and tasted like true "Key Lime" cheesecake. We wish you had a store closer to this area. Keep up the excellent work!

E. and G., Greensburg, PA

This cheesecake is ridiculous. Ten stars. I had the caramel apple. They also gave me a free cookie.

Mike C., Pittsburgh, PA

The key lime was phenomenal. You have a new customer for life. It was great meeting you. I love family businesses who do something special as you and your mom do.

Gary S., Pittsburgh, PA

The Triple Chocolate cheesecake is phenomenal!! My wife bought it from I Made It Market today and surprised me with it.

I fell in love with the first bite... flavors are so rich, yet it's very smooth and easy to eat.
You taste it with your heart not your mouth.
Thanks for whomever made it.. you made my night.

Ahmad A., Pittsburgh, PA

Well, after I picked up a Key Lime & Classic with Strawberry sauce...l went home and did my yard work.

Once finished, I dug into those cakes. OMG, my taste buds went crazy. I definitely will be back for more. I LOVE em, some of the Best I've ever had.

Richard B., Pittsburgh, PA

Just wanted to say THANK YOU for the key lime cheesecake -- I bought this for my husband's birthday and never have I heard him gush about a cheesecake before. And he is NOT a gusher, LOL. At least four times this weekend he mentioned this cheesecake unprompted, so safe to say it was a hit. Thank you again, and we hope to try another flavor very soon!

Amy O., Pittsburgh, PA

My wife and I married this autumn and your cheesecakes were a huge thing between us meeting, eating far too much, and just having such warm feelings. Thank you for making awesome food.

Jake W., Aliquippa, PA

Just wanted to say that I bought a few of your cheesecakes at the farmer’s market yesterday and brought them into the office.

This is phenomenal!!  I foolishly brought a container for leftovers but I expect that if I go back into the kitchen there isn’t going to be a single crumb left.  Fortunately I took a small bite of each flavor for myself.

Thank you!  I will be back to see you in a few weeks.

Cathy W., Pittsburgh, PA

More Testimonials